On December 10, 2024, Detective Ben Hines of the Monticello Police Department conducted a traffic stop after observing what appeared to be a physical altercation between the driver and passenger of a vehicle. As he approached the car, Detective Hines testified that he saw the defendant, Ms. Shook, place her hand near the side of her seat. A subsequent search of the vehicle by Hines and other officers led to the discovery of a glass pipe—commonly used to ingest methamphetamine—stuffed in the seat where Ms. Shook’s hand had been seen. Ms. Shook was taken into custody, fingerprinted at the jail, and later released.

Ms. Shook was charged as a habitual offender based on her three prior convictions. Under Arkansas law, a person may be designated a habitual offender if they have multiple prior felony convictions. At the time of her arrest, Ms. Shook had three prior convictions for drug paraphernalia from events that arose on July 28^th, 2020, October 27^th,  2020, and December 31^st, 2020, all for possession of drug paraphernalia used to ingest methamphetamine. She had completed probation on those offenses in January 2024.

A jury trial was held on June 24, 2025, at the Drew County Courthouse. Jurors heard testimony from Detective Hines, other responding officers, and an expert from the Arkansas State Crime Lab who tested the glass pipe and confirmed the presence of methamphetamine residue.

After considering all the evidence presented at trial, the jury found Ms. Shook not guilty.